NABBA Britain Results

***PScarb*** · 21-05-2006, 10:23 AM

Masters Over 40
6th Paul Dillon
5th Mark Stocks
4th Sid Connor
3rd Alan Sheldon
2nd Robert Turner
1st Dave Steele

Over 50's
6th Robert Young
5th Al Zebiela
4th Sam Metcalfe
3rd Ronnie King
2nd Vince Delasandri
1st Gerry Morgan

Juniors
6th Paul Mettan
5th Chris Ormrod
4th Joseph Boyd
3rd Nathan Daesha
2nd Aidan Travers
1st John Patrick Martin

Miss Figure Toned
6th Victoria Goodall
5th Kirsten Cameron
4th Andrea Bateman
3rd Andi Black
2nd Lynn Carmichael
1st Jayne Tingle

Miss Figure class 2
6th Anita Kenyon
5th Tina Moore
4th Lisa Mann
3rd Cheryl Steele
2nd Louise Thornton
1st Rachel Grice

Miss Figure class 1
6th Jane Brooks
5th Joanne Sperring
4th Rhiann George
3rd Adele Gibbon
2nd Malika Zitouni
1st Karen Bricklebank

Class 4 Men
6th Simon Horsell
5th Steve Wright
4th Lee Callaghan
3rd Andrew Henry
2nd Steve Flynn
1st Wayne Jones

Class 3
6th Edward Srlsby
5th Shane Watson
4th Bruce Mekrll
3rd Gary Haliwell
2nd Justin Trollope
1st Roy Pattison

Class 2
6th Barry Vormahaw
5th Jon Bridge
4th David Bell
3rd Gary Keith
2nd David Fox
1st Paul Longfield

Class 1
6th James Scott
5th Andy Jameson
4th Lee Mororae
3rd Steven Baker
2nd Ken Prescott
1st Marty Fannan

Miss Fitness
4th Ruth Scott
3rd Rachel Murray
2nd Martyna Kulin
1st Helen Heanon

Ladies Overall Karen Bricklebank
Mens Overall Paul Longfield

kriptikchicken · 21-05-2006, 02:56 PM

Thanks for the swift results Mr Carbs,

***Extreme*** · 21-05-2006, 09:16 PM

The judging was well out in some classes, this show is the worst judged NABBA show I've seen.

Steve Baker in class 1 was not in a fit state to take part in the comparisons and I think he missed some of the compulsories if not them all, he rallied round enough to take part in 1 comparison which they requested after the judges had finished judging the class. The judges were asked before the night show where Steve Baker would have placed if he had been able to compete in all parts of the judging, the judges said where he could have came and so he was given that placing.

How can that be fair on all the other guys in the class who sweated their bollox off doing qtr turns, posing, multiple comparisons only to place behind a guy who took part in 30% of the supposed judging?

I don't know Stevie well but I know him to speak to and he is a sound guy who is serous about his bodybuilding, so I felt sorry for him BUT if you are prepared to push things to drop fluid you need to accept it can go wrong, in this case it did unfortunately. He knows what can happen and took the risk, he should not have placed in this event because he did not take part in it all.

If you enter triathalon you swin, cycle and run, you can't win without completing all 3 parts, the same applies here.

Also in class one 4th place should not have gone to Lee Mororoe, he was too soft by miles, the guy has mammoth potential but that should not earn you a trophy you don't deserve.

Dave Fox or John Bridge should have been winner and runner up of class 2, martin fannon was the easy winner of class won (they got that right), Justin Trollope pushed Roy Pattison all the way in class 3 and has every right to feel hard done by because it could have gone either way.

I never saw class 4 but according to people whose judgement I trust, Musclechat member Steve Flynn was hard done by.

Rachael Grice - Musclechat moderator "Bettyboo" was awesome, her and boyfriend Shane Copley (our own Bodyworks) have awesome potential, both are young and have a long future ahead in bodybuilding because they are phenomenal bodybuilders and really nice people with their feet on the ground.

Also they keep changing the judging panel from class to class, how is it possible then to gain any consistency from class to class? In a subjective decision making sport you need to have consistency in those actually making the decisions if you are to keep consistency in the judgements.

www.extremenutrition.co.uk
www.gasp-uk.com

steve flynn · 22-05-2006, 10:42 AM

Dougie.. "I never saw class 4 but according to people whose judgement I trust, Musclechat member Steve Flynn was hard done by."

.. bit gutted mate, but coming round now.. first let me give congrats to the winner of my class, wayne jones, nice bloke & top physique. im the first to accept being beaten fair and square, but on this occasion i was a little bewildered,especially as the callouts gave every sign in my favour. i won't go on about this cos it will sound like every other story we hear when a guy misses out. ill just let others who were at the show to do my talking for me..

, as it turns out it was a tie for first place..wayne and myself..so it went down to individual judges first placings given..he beat me 4-3..

but i will say the judges DO have a tough job and sometimes a thankless one, and when we step onstage we accept that human decisions are going to be made..and sometimes they may not go in our favour..(this is me trying to be philosophic about it whilst still gutted LOL..

)

not one single shredded guy won a mens class on saturday..??? puzzled i am to say the least...

bodyworks.. thankyou mate.. your comments to me, and what you said to nick about me were very welcome bud..

bettyboo.....what can i say !!! you got exactly what you deserved.. you were awesome rach, no other words for it.. a true champ.. see you both soon...

steve

kirstenc · 22-05-2006, 06:04 PM

Was a great show, and would like to thank Dougie and Jo for their help this last few months and tanning me up and having my vodka at the ready at the bar for when i came off stage!! Thanks both of u!

''bettyboo'' · 22-05-2006, 07:24 PM

hi steve

all the comments were ture, we both thought it was the best we have ever seen you, the placing wasnt the one you deserved how ever they way you looked on saturday you should be over the moon, and it should just make you more determined for next time. hopefully i'll be the one losing my voice at the brits nexts time i'll have a few of you to cheer for you, shane, alan, louise i'll be a nervous wreck. Enjoy your food i know we are.

xxx

Young Gun · 22-05-2006, 08:40 PM

Well done to everyone on the board who competed anyone got pictures

**LeeB** · 23-05-2006, 09:10 AM

totally agree about baker. hes a great lad with a fantastic physique and i really wanted to see him do well as i think at his best it was his for the taking! much respect!

i wasnt there but have been told what happened.

if you cant actually compete in the pre-judging.. then surely you cant get placed???

**Bodyworks** · 23-05-2006, 01:22 PM

to steve flynn, you know you were hard done by, but your reaction to the placing you got speaks volumes about the kind of man you are. got nothing but respect for ya mate.

21-05-2006, 10:23 AM	#1 (permalink)
*PScarb* Super Moderator Super Moderator Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 1,012 Rep Power:	NABBA Britain Results Masters Over 40 6th Paul Dillon 5th Mark Stocks 4th Sid Connor 3rd Alan Sheldon 2nd Robert Turner 1st Dave Steele Over 50's 6th Robert Young 5th Al Zebiela 4th Sam Metcalfe 3rd Ronnie King 2nd Vince Delasandri 1st Gerry Morgan Juniors 6th Paul Mettan 5th Chris Ormrod 4th Joseph Boyd 3rd Nathan Daesha 2nd Aidan Travers 1st John Patrick Martin Miss Figure Toned 6th Victoria Goodall 5th Kirsten Cameron 4th Andrea Bateman 3rd Andi Black 2nd Lynn Carmichael 1st Jayne Tingle Miss Figure class 2 6th Anita Kenyon 5th Tina Moore 4th Lisa Mann 3rd Cheryl Steele 2nd Louise Thornton 1st Rachel Grice Miss Figure class 1 6th Jane Brooks 5th Joanne Sperring 4th Rhiann George 3rd Adele Gibbon 2nd Malika Zitouni 1st Karen Bricklebank Class 4 Men 6th Simon Horsell 5th Steve Wright 4th Lee Callaghan 3rd Andrew Henry 2nd Steve Flynn 1st Wayne Jones Class 3 6th Edward Srlsby 5th Shane Watson 4th Bruce Mekrll 3rd Gary Haliwell 2nd Justin Trollope 1st Roy Pattison Class 2 6th Barry Vormahaw 5th Jon Bridge 4th David Bell 3rd Gary Keith 2nd David Fox 1st Paul Longfield Class 1 6th James Scott 5th Andy Jameson 4th Lee Mororae 3rd Steven Baker 2nd Ken Prescott 1st Marty Fannan Miss Fitness 4th Ruth Scott 3rd Rachel Murray 2nd Martyna Kulin 1st Helen Heanon Ladies Overall Karen Bricklebank Mens Overall Paul Longfield

21-05-2006, 09:16 PM	#3 (permalink)
*Extreme* Super Moderator Super Moderator Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: UK Posts: 1,330 Rep Power:	The judging was well out in some classes, this show is the worst judged NABBA show I've seen. Steve Baker in class 1 was not in a fit state to take part in the comparisons and I think he missed some of the compulsories if not them all, he rallied round enough to take part in 1 comparison which they requested after the judges had finished judging the class. The judges were asked before the night show where Steve Baker would have placed if he had been able to compete in all parts of the judging, the judges said where he could have came and so he was given that placing. How can that be fair on all the other guys in the class who sweated their bollox off doing qtr turns, posing, multiple comparisons only to place behind a guy who took part in 30% of the supposed judging? I don't know Stevie well but I know him to speak to and he is a sound guy who is serous about his bodybuilding, so I felt sorry for him BUT if you are prepared to push things to drop fluid you need to accept it can go wrong, in this case it did unfortunately. He knows what can happen and took the risk, he should not have placed in this event because he did not take part in it all. If you enter triathalon you swin, cycle and run, you can't win without completing all 3 parts, the same applies here. Also in class one 4th place should not have gone to Lee Mororoe, he was too soft by miles, the guy has mammoth potential but that should not earn you a trophy you don't deserve. Dave Fox or John Bridge should have been winner and runner up of class 2, martin fannon was the easy winner of class won (they got that right), Justin Trollope pushed Roy Pattison all the way in class 3 and has every right to feel hard done by because it could have gone either way. I never saw class 4 but according to people whose judgement I trust, Musclechat member Steve Flynn was hard done by. Rachael Grice - Musclechat moderator "Bettyboo" was awesome, her and boyfriend Shane Copley (our own Bodyworks) have awesome potential, both are young and have a long future ahead in bodybuilding because they are phenomenal bodybuilders and really nice people with their feet on the ground. Also they keep changing the judging panel from class to class, how is it possible then to gain any consistency from class to class? In a subjective decision making sport you need to have consistency in those actually making the decisions if you are to keep consistency in the judgements. www.extremenutrition.co.uk www.gasp-uk.com ______________________ www.extremenutrition.co.uk - 25% OFF FOR ALL MC MEMBERS, discount code MCD25. www.betterbodies.uk.com Seriously cheap sports nutrition! DYNALYNE, the strongest fat burner ever, ONLY £24.95!

23-05-2006, 09:10 AM	#8 (permalink)
LeeB Moderator Musclechat Icon Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 1,925 Rep Power:	totally agree about baker. hes a great lad with a fantastic physique and i really wanted to see him do well as i think at his best it was his for the taking! much respect! i wasnt there but have been told what happened. if you cant actually compete in the pre-judging.. then surely you cant get placed??? ______________________ If your not a part of the greatest... you got to be the greatest yourself! For the best supplements: www.extremenutrition.co.uk

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

21-05-2006, 02:56 PM	#2 (permalink)
kriptikchicken Making Progress Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Edinburgh Posts: 157 Rep Power:	Thanks for the swift results Mr Carbs,

22-05-2006, 10:42 AM	#4 (permalink)
steve flynn Under Construction Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 68 Rep Power:	Dougie.. "I never saw class 4 but according to people whose judgement I trust, Musclechat member Steve Flynn was hard done by." .. bit gutted mate, but coming round now.. first let me give congrats to the winner of my class, wayne jones, nice bloke & top physique. im the first to accept being beaten fair and square, but on this occasion i was a little bewildered,especially as the callouts gave every sign in my favour. i won't go on about this cos it will sound like every other story we hear when a guy misses out. ill just let others who were at the show to do my talking for me.. , as it turns out it was a tie for first place..wayne and myself..so it went down to individual judges first placings given..he beat me 4-3.. but i will say the judges DO have a tough job and sometimes a thankless one, and when we step onstage we accept that human decisions are going to be made..and sometimes they may not go in our favour..(this is me trying to be philosophic about it whilst still gutted LOL.. ) not one single shredded guy won a mens class on saturday..??? puzzled i am to say the least... bodyworks.. thankyou mate.. your comments to me, and what you said to nick about me were very welcome bud.. bettyboo.....what can i say !!! you got exactly what you deserved.. you were awesome rach, no other words for it.. a true champ.. see you both soon... steve

22-05-2006, 06:04 PM	#5 (permalink)
kirstenc Under Construction Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: back to edinburgh Posts: 43 Rep Power:	Was a great show, and would like to thank Dougie and Jo for their help this last few months and tanning me up and having my vodka at the ready at the bar for when i came off stage!! Thanks both of u!

22-05-2006, 07:24 PM	#6 (permalink)
''bettyboo'' Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: my own little world most of the day Posts: 212 Rep Power:	hi steve all the comments were ture, we both thought it was the best we have ever seen you, the placing wasnt the one you deserved how ever they way you looked on saturday you should be over the moon, and it should just make you more determined for next time. hopefully i'll be the one losing my voice at the brits nexts time i'll have a few of you to cheer for you, shane, alan, louise i'll be a nervous wreck. Enjoy your food i know we are. xxx

22-05-2006, 08:40 PM	#7 (permalink)
Young Gun Illuminati Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 1,539 Rep Power:	Well done to everyone on the board who competed anyone got pictures

23-05-2006, 01:22 PM	#9 (permalink)
Bodyworks Moderator Musclechat Icon Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: west yorkshire Posts: 977 Rep Power:	to steve flynn, you know you were hard done by, but your reaction to the placing you got speaks volumes about the kind of man you are. got nothing but respect for ya mate.